Clicky

Best Baby Crib Mattress Reviews

When it comes to planning a nursery for a new addition to the family, baby safety is a major concern for all parents, grandparents, and caregivers. Therefore, many of these people will spend months searching through the various types of toys, clothing, bedding, car seats and more to make sure they choose only the best for the baby that will soon join their lives. One of the biggest concerns for parents is where to let the baby sleep. What kind of mattress is best? How do you know that you are getting a safe mattress? To help, we have dedicated ourselves to bringing you the best reviews on all of the most popular baby brands. We put effort into our baby mattress reviews to help you save time searching through endless products, so that you can spend your time on things that matter much more, your family.

The Baby Crib Mattress Review Specialist

When it comes to comfort and safety when dealing with a newborn’s bed, you cannot be too careful. You need a mattress that is comfortable, breathable, and one that you can rest easy knowing is the best possible in terms of quality and safety. However, this is where it gets a little tricky. It is recommended that newborn and babies up to toddler age, sleep on a firm surface. For many parents this may not seem like the most comfortable place for baby, especially a newborn.

The truth is, just because you feel the mattress may be too firm, it does not always mean that it is too firm for the baby. Babies weigh very little and they do not have a lot of body mass, this can make a surface that you feel is uncomfortable, very comfortable for them. Often on a firmer crib mattress, newborns will start sleeping through the night easier. That is why we are so committed to helping parents find only the best and safest baby crib mattresses on the market.

Crib MattressMaterialRatingPriceDetailed Review
Simmons Kids Beautyrest
Simmons Beautyrest Crib Mattress
Cotton Cover4.2$$$Full Review
Colgate Eco Classic
ColgateCribMattress
Cotton Cover4.3$$$Full Review
My First Mattress
My First Mattress Baby Crib Mattress
Foam4.5$$Full Review
Naturepedic Organic
NaturepedicOrganic
Organic Cotton4.4$$$$Full Review
Sealy Soybean Foam
Sealy Soybean Foam Mattress
Soybean Foam4.7$$$Full Review
Safety 1st
Safety 1st Water Proof Cover
Vinyl Surface4.3$Full Review
Lullaby Earth
Lullaby Earth Mattress Review
Food-grade Polyethylene4.6$$$$Full Review

Baby Crib Mattress Purchasing Factors

There are several things you need to consider when it comes to crib mattresses. There are very few parents who simply walk into a store and grab the first one they see. This is because the internet makes it easy to learn all there is to know about a crib mattress, before you buy. With that being said, there are key things that you should look for in a mattress, beyond whether it can be used for both infants and toddlers, which most can.

Safety

The safety of a crib mattress is definitely something you should check out before you make a purchase. Most will state that they are safe, but are they? Most of them are 100% baby friendly. Many are made with materials that will not absorb allergens, they may be filled with special foam to ensure that they remain hypoallergenic. One concern parents often has is the smell of the mattes when the plastic wrapping is removed. This shouldn’t come as a surprise as many baby mattress do have a chemical odor. Although the mattress meets safety requirement standards, like us, most parents prefer no odor for their newborn mattress. Safety should be amongst the top priority when purchasing a new baby crib mattress.

Comfort

Next, you must look at the comfort factor. A firm sleeping surface is best, but if you get a plastic covered mattress, your infant may get too hot during the night. Just like parents, a hot and sweaty sleeping environment is not conducive to a good nights sleep for an infant or toddler. Therefore, you may want to find a mattress that is firm, but not hard and one that has a more cloth-like or breathable fabric over it.

Price

For many families, price is also a concern. You have a lot of expenses when it comes to bringing home a little one. There are so many things that you will need to purchase, and let’s face it, not a whole lot of time to figure it all out. With crib mattresses, there is a huge price variation. Some will cost you about $100, but there are a lot more that are well above that price. Do you really need the higher end mattress? If you are looking for a crib mattress made of higher quality filling, or stitched so there are no seams, and possess other features or name brands that some parents prefer, you can expect to pay a premium price. You have to decide what you can afford and what you feel meets your expectations for the price.

Waterproof Cover

Some crib mattresses come with a cover and some do not. You need to figure out which type you want. There are covered mattresses that are removable and some that are not. Some covers are designed to help lessen the plastic feel that may be required to ensure it is hypoallergenic. A lot of the covers are waterproof for added safety and peace of mind for parents. Others are not waterproof, but they can be tossed into a washing machine. These crib mattress covers can save you money on crib sheets if you are in a pinch, but most parents who have a covered mattress still prefer to use crib sheets to increase protection and comfort of their little one. This is a personal preference that only you can decide which way is best for you and your little one.

Our Picks for the Top 5 Best Crib Mattresses

After searching through all of the reviews on various crib mattresses, we have come up with our preferred top 5 based on current owner reviews, price range, and overall quality rating. Perhaps one of these will spark your interest and if so, there are longer reviews for each of these products available. The only thing that truly matters is that you discover the best baby mattress for you, your little one, and your family’s budget.

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Crib Mattress

Simmons Beautyrest Crib MattressThe Simmons Kids Beautyrest crib mattress is amongst the best based on the large volume of reviews it has received. The Kids Beautyrest uses pocketed coil springs which is a little uncommon in today’s crib mattresses. It is not the most expensive,  but yet not the cheapest mattress either but it does come with free shipping. It is a crib mattress that is made in the USA and meets all of the rigorous requirements and standards that we value when it comes to only the best baby mattress available. Read Our Full Review⇒

 

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

Moonlight Slumber Mattress ReviewThis mattress is a little higher priced at nearly $200, but this is the only real reason it is not in the number one spot. Parents love it, and it is one of the most popular mattresses available for both infants and toddlers. It is filled with high-density foam and free of all chemicals and materials that could harm a growing baby. If ever you do have a problem with this mattress, there is a support team who are more than willing to help you reach a satisfactory resolution to it. Read Our Full Review⇒

 

Naturepedic Organic Cotton Crib

NaturepedicOrganicWith a price tag nearing $300, this is one of the most expensive crib mattresses available. However, this organic cotton crib mattress still has a dedicated following. There are people who swear that it is the best mattress available and that it is able to last from birth through toddlerhood without ever showing signs of wear. One of the best features of this mattress in comparison to the top two is that it is absolutely waterproof and it is filled with nothing more than organic cotton. Read Our Full Review⇒

 

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

 

Sealy Soybean Foam MattressWhen people hear soybean foam mattress, they often picture tiny beans inside of a mattress. This is not true. This mattress has a foam core that is infused with soybean oils to eliminate possible allergens. It is made in the USA and uses only soybean oils that are from the USA. The soybean oil’s benefits do not stop at the mattress. It promotes an overall healthier indoor environment, for the very low price. It is a mattress that most people are willing to consider, even though it falls short compared with others that are foam filled. Full Sealy Soybean Review Here⇒

Colgate Eco Classica III

 

ColgateCribMattressAccording to some owners of the Colgate baby mattress reviews, this could be higher on our list. It is comparable in price to other mattresses and meets all of the same safety requirements of other mattresses within our list. However, it does have a plastic feel to it when the organic cotton cover is not on. For some people, they do not want the plastic, but others feel that the cotton cover makes it better. You will have to decide for yourself on this one. Full Eco Classic Review Here⇒